About law, economics, human rights and sports.

Sport Slavery: The NCAA and CHL exploitation of teenagers.

This is a scholarly academic treatise about how law can best stop the systemic and systematic monetization of teenage super talent by ‘mock-amateur’ for-profit NCAA Division I football & basketball, and CHL Major Junior ice hockey sport cartels, by virtue of a 100% equity for all cartel athletes “PLAY ME–PAY ME” fair payment model for what is an elite-expert young labor force with its rare bundle of services and conditions, a model intended to also improve the prosperity of the NCAA & CHL, and a work also intended to draw much overdue attention to US & Canada’s inferior and unacceptable child labor protection laws.

Part I

US /Canada Labor Law

US/Canada Child Labor Law

NCAA/CHL Sport Cartel Labor Treatment

Teenage athletes represent fractured child labor laws and protection

Part II & Part III

Investigation & Analysis 

US/Canada Statute Law 

US/Canada Case Law

US/Canada Executive Public Inquiry Law

World Child Labor Directives

Part IV

Recommendations

US/Canada Public Inquiry

Play Me Pay Me Model

All Rights Recaptured

NCAA & CHL Public Role

Conclusion For Justice

Investigating the Conditions

The Current Conditions

A detailed description of the NCAA and CHL sport cartel exploitation of teenage labor that also includes numerous other rights exploited, as well as providing a detailed description of the overall exploitation of the child labor force past and present in the US and in Canada.  

Sport Slavery Treatise Part I

The Law Conditions

A detailed description of the US and Canadian Statute Law in place to protect labor rights, legal rights, and overall human rights of children and adults.  Summaries and field studies of three current high profile cases against the NCAA and CHL are detailed from the US and Canadian courts. 

Sport Slavery Treatise Part II & Part III

The Future Conditions

Recommendations, conclusions and projections for the protection of the human rights and financial rights of teenage athletes working in the NCAA and CHL, with commentary also on the benefit of this issue as a lead example for improvements to the entire child labor force in US/Canada.

Sport Slavery Treatise Part IV

About Me

My name is Susan MacDonald.  I am the researcher and author of this treatise work.

I am a Master of Human Kinetics in the area of High Performance Coaching Science (1999).  I am also the recipient of the Petro Canada Canadian Olympic Coaching Award of Excellence in Canada (1997-1998), for my development of high performance athletes in Men’s Ice Hockey.  I am the founder and director of a high performance development program for athletes called IcePower High Performance, where I have developed athletes, male and female, from Canada and US from 1996 to 2019.   

I am also a Juris Doctor (2004) and a Master of Laws (2019).  The treatise available here is the scholarly work of the Master of Laws released for publication by the University of British Columbia on January 29, 2025, which is a delayed release due to an author imposed Embargo from 2019 to present.

I thank the University of British Columbia and my excellent mentoring world-class professors of law, Professor Joseph Weiler, and Associate Dean, Dr. Graham Reynolds for their gifted guidance on this very large project. 

I have seen hundreds of my athletes, including family members, enjoy playing for the NCAA and/or the CHL, and the lower Junior A Tier II men’s ice hockey, but with a rock in my gut for them, I’ve watched others profit off their labor, name-image-likeness, their super talent and toughness, with nothing to each young man in return.  I’ve watched their contract terms dissolve in the pressures of living life on the vapor of a rainbow of their dreams.  While everyone around them, from event ticket-taker to arena cleaning people all made a wage for the event, the performing stars were guaranteed zero.  To me, the law seemed to miss a beat, and I wanted to find out why this relationship between sport cartels and thousands of youth was not cut short and the kids paid at least minimum wage if the owners were operating cartel franchises worth millions of dollars.

I wanted to do this five year work in the form of treatise for the benefit of those who do not know the life of the child worker, and the life of a youth that is gifted, and controlled by a powerful cartel.  I wanted to know the failures in the law, in economics, in the courts, media, and society.  I wanted to open the eyes of the judges, commissioners, lawyers, lawmakers and scholars.   I wanted to get the athletes paid if they were part of a billion dollar sport cartel, but to do it in a way that the NCAA and CHL continue to prosper.  I believe I have done that, i have found the problems, and discovered solutions.

Sport Slavery treatise is a demand for a PLAY ME–PAY ME reality that is intended not only to  benefit young gifted athletes, but also benefit all child labor in the many industries throughout the US and Canada that are exploiting children. 

Yours, in the development of fine young men and women through sport, and to those who cannot quit their dreams,

 

Susan D. MacDonald, BHK, MHK, JD, LLM.

“The player is trapped because he cannot quit his dreams.”

Susan D. MacDonald, BHK, MHK, JD, LLM.

British Columbia, Canada

Contact Us

Contact us if you have further questions or suggestions.